On the 20th anniversary of the horrific Christmas Eve murders at St. Agnes, a demonic preacher from the past returns to haunt the residents of the same town. Among them is Salem, a young man whose once happy life is ripped from him piece by piece as he is framed for an unspeakable crime. The only one who believes in his innocence is a heartbroken call girl (Alexis Knapp) who herself is having nightmares. Together and individually, they are forced to face their own demons, as well as a real one named Mr. Monday.